In the 1920s, amid Florida’s legendary land boom, a small Gulf Coast town would become the canvas for one of America’s most distinguished urban planners. John Nolen, a visionary who studied at Harvard and apprenticed with Frederick Law Olmsted Jr., was commissioned to design Venice, Florida—a project that would become one of his most enduring legacies. Today, nearly a century later, his influence remains visible in every tree-lined boulevard and Mediterranean-inspired building that gives Venice its distinctive charm.
The Brotherhood’s Bold Vision
The story begins when the Brotherhood of Locomotive Engineers (BLE), a labor union flush with pension funds, purchased 30,000 acres of Florida land in 1925. Rather than pursuing the haphazard development common during Florida’s land boom, the BLE took an unusual approach. They hired John Nolen, already respected for his work in planning communities from San Diego to Charlotte, to create a comprehensive city plan from scratch.
Nolen was given a rare opportunity that few urban planners ever receive—the chance to design an entire city from the ground up. His vision for Venice wasn’t just about streets and buildings; it was about creating a livable, beautiful community that would stand the test of time.
Mediterranean Revival: The Architectural Heartbeat of Venice
Perhaps the most immediately recognizable element of Nolen’s plan was his insistence on Mediterranean Revival architecture. This style, characterized by stucco walls, red tile roofs, arched doorways, and wrought iron accents, was perfectly suited to Florida’s climate and light. Nolen believed that architecture should harmonize with the natural environment, and the Mediterranean Revival style accomplished this beautifully.
The BLE hired New York architect Prentiss French to oversee architectural standards, ensuring that all buildings conformed to this unified aesthetic. The Hotel Venice (now known as the Venice Centre Mall) became the crowning jewel of this architectural vision when it opened in 1926, establishing the city’s distinctive look that continues to define its character today.
Beyond Beauty: Practical Urban Planning
Nolen’s genius extended far beyond aesthetics. His plan for Venice addressed practical concerns with remarkable foresight:
- A Grid System with Purpose: Unlike the rigid grid layouts of many American cities, Nolen designed Venice’s streets to follow gentle curves that followed natural contours of the land. Major thoroughfares like Venice Avenue were designed with generous width to accommodate traffic, while neighborhood streets were kept narrower to discourage speeding.
- Parks and Green Spaces: Nolen integrated parks throughout the city plan, ensuring that residents would always have access to natural spaces. His concept of “parkways”—broad, tree-lined thoroughfares that served as linear parks themselves—remains one of Venice’s most cherished features.
- Mixed-Use Development: Long before it became trendy in urban planning, Nolen insisted on incorporating commercial, residential, and recreational spaces in close proximity, creating walkable neighborhoods where residents could meet their daily needs without relying heavily on automobiles.
- Social Infrastructure: Nolen’s plan included sites for schools, churches, and community gathering places, recognizing that a city is more than just buildings and streets—it’s a social ecosystem.
Preserving the Vision Through Challenges
The stock market crash of 1929 and subsequent Great Depression nearly derailed Nolen’s vision. Construction halted, the BLE withdrew from the project, and many wondered if Venice would ever fulfill its potential. However, the foundation Nolen had established was so strong that even during these lean years, the essential character of the city remained intact.
After World War II, when development resumed, city leaders made the crucial decision to honor Nolen’s original plan. While many Florida communities surrendered to suburban sprawl and architectural chaos in the post-war boom, Venice maintained its commitment to Nolen’s vision of a coherent, beautiful city.
Venice Today: Living in a Masterpiece
Walking through Venice today is like strolling through the pages of Nolen’s original drawings. The wide, palm-lined Venice Avenue leads visitors from the Intracoastal Waterway to the Gulf of Mexico, passing through a downtown district where Mediterranean Revival buildings house shops, restaurants, and cultural amenities. The parks Nolen envisioned provide green respite throughout the city, and his thoughtful street layout continues to serve residents and visitors alike.
In 1989, the city’s historic district was placed on the National Register of Historic Places, recognizing the enduring value of Nolen’s work. While many planned communities of the 1920s have lost their character to subsequent development, Venice stands as a testament to the power of thoughtful urban planning.
The Legacy Continues
John Nolen’s influence extends beyond Venice’s physical layout. His philosophy—that cities should be beautiful, functional, and designed with human well-being as the primary concern—continues to inform how Venice approaches development today. The city’s planning department and Historic Preservation Board work diligently to ensure that new construction respects the architectural heritage Nolen established.
As communities across America rediscover the value of walkable neighborhoods, mixed-use development, and architectural coherence, Venice stands as a model of what these principles can achieve when applied consistently over time. Nearly a century after Nolen first put pencil to paper, his vision continues to shape daily life for everyone who lives in or visits this Gulf Coast gem.
In an era of rapid development and changing tastes, Venice, Florida remains a living testament to the enduring power of good design. John Nolen may have passed away in 1937, but his legacy lives on in every red-tiled roof and graceful palm-lined avenue of the city he designed to last for generations.
VENICE BARBERSHOP
Where traditional barbering never goes out of style
3956 South Tamiami Trail Venice, FL
Next to the Courthouse & Tax Collector building.
941-716-7570
Walk-Ins Only
Cash Only
Follow us on Facebook